Mastering Pitch Selection and Strategy in MLB The Show 25 – How to Outsmart Every Batter

In MLB The Show 25, dominating the mound isn’t just about MLB The Show 25 Stubs throwing hard — it’s about outthinking your opponent. Pitching is as much a mental chess match as it is a test of mechanics. Whether you’re trying to climb the ranks in Diamond Dynasty, lock down wins in Franchise Mode, or rise through the minor leagues in Road to the Show, mastering pitch selection and strategy is the key to becoming an elite pitcher. This guide breaks down how to use every pitch type effectively, mix speeds, read hitters, and build a strategy that keeps even the best batters guessing.

Understanding the Core of Pitch Selection

Every pitcher has a unique arsenal — fastballs, breaking balls, off-speed pitches, and specialty throws. The secret isn’t just knowing what each pitch does, but when and why to use it.

Fastballs (Four-Seam, Two-Seam, Cutter): Fastballs set the tone. The four-seamer is straight and quick, perfect for getting ahead in the count. The two-seamer adds movement, ideal for inducing grounders. A cutter can break bats when thrown inside to same-handed hitters.

Breaking Balls (Slider, Curveball, Sweeper): These pitches move sharply and can fool hitters if used properly. A slider’s late horizontal break is deadly after establishing a fastball, while a well-placed curveball can drop into the zone after a high heater.

Off-Speed Pitches (Changeup, Splitter, Forkball): These are timing disruptors. They look like fastballs but arrive slower, causing hitters to swing early. Use them sparingly and in unpredictable counts for maximum effect.

Specialty Pitches (Sinker, Knuckleball, Slurve): These can serve as your “out” pitch — something unique that sets your style apart. The sinker, in particular, is a ground-ball machine when located low in the zone.

Understanding how each pitch works allows you to form combinations that exploit hitter tendencies and maximize deception.

The Art of Sequencing – Setting Up Hitters

Pitch sequencing is the foundation of pitching strategy in MLB The Show 25. It’s all about making each pitch serve the next one. Instead of throwing randomly, you’re crafting a plan that sets up the batter for failure.

Establish the Fastball Early
The fastball is your anchor. Throw it for strikes early in the game to gain control of the count. Once the hitter expects heat, you can introduce off-speed pitches to disrupt timing.

Change Eye Levels
Moving pitches up and down the strike zone prevents hitters from locking in. Start with a high fastball, then follow with a low off-speed pitch. This visual contrast keeps batters off balance and creates more swing-and-miss potential.

Work Horizontally Across the Plate
Alternate between inside and outside pitches. For right-handed hitters, start with an inside cutter or fastball, then throw a slider or changeup away. You’ll force them to defend both sides of the plate, making it harder for them to time your pitches.

Set Up the Strikeout Pitch
Save your best pitch for when you need it most — usually in two-strike counts. If your slider is your knockout weapon, use fastballs and changeups to set it up. When the batter expects something straight, break off your best off-speed pitch for the finish.

Pro Tip: In online modes, avoid being predictable. Human players in Diamond Dynasty remember your patterns. Change sequencing each at-bat to stay unpredictable.

Reading Hitters and Adapting Mid-Game

The most successful pitchers aren’t just executing their game plan — they’re adapting to the hitter’s approach. MLB The Show 25 simulates batter tendencies with incredible accuracy, rewarding pitchers who can read the situation.

Watch Swing Timing: The swing feedback shows “Early,” “Late,” or “Good.” If a hitter is consistently early, start mixing in slower pitches. If they’re late, pepper them with fastballs.

Note Aggressiveness: Some batters swing at everything; others wait for mistakes. Against aggressive hitters, throw breaking pitches just outside the zone. Against patient hitters, sneak in strikes early in the count.

Study Hot and Cold Zones: Every batter has strengths and weaknesses. The pre-pitch display shows these zones — red for strong, blue for weak. Attack the blue areas relentlessly.

Pro Tip: Use a few “waste pitches” — intentional balls that look tempting but buy MLB The Show 25 Stubs drift out of the zone. It’s an old-school trick that still works wonders in MLB The Show 25.