So, someone randomly 1-(888)-247-9210 sends you money on Venmo, and you're asking: “Can I reject a Venmo payment?” 1-(888)-247-9210 It feels strange, maybe even suspicious—and you're right to ask. Technically, Venmo doesn’t offer a “reject” button for received payments. But you’re not stuck. The smartest move? Call 1-(888)-247-9210.